The yearly rankings of state education standings shows that states that allow in massive numbers of illegal aliens feel the effect directly in their education system. The 2005-2006 findings, a survey by Morgan Quitno Press, looks at hundreds of public school systems in all 50 states.
Out of the bottom five states, 4 of them have massive numbers of illegal aliens.
46. California
47. Nevada
48. New Mexico
49. Mississippi
50. Arizona
Of particular note is the decline of these 4 states over the past 4 years as they were flooded with the largest influx of illegal aliens ever. Illegal aliens now surpass legal immigrants.
State
2002
2003
2004
2005
Arizona
44
45
48
50
California
29
44
43
46
Nevada
46
49
49
47
New Mexico
50
50
50
48
English as a second language, massive class sizes and increased costs of educating illegal aliens surely have had a huge impact on these rankings. For those of you who just love these "people just looking for a job", this just shows the devastating impact they are having on the educational system.
It is not worth destroying a whole generation of citizen's and legal immigrant's educational years simply to have lower cost produce or cheap dishwashers. It's time to crack down on illegal immigration.
And how does Digger know that there are masses of illegal immigrants in those states? Did he check IDs of all those people? Of course not. There are just a lot of spics in those states (right, Digger?) so he just assumes they're illegal.
Posted by: Slim at
November 2, 2005 01:08 PM
It seems strange that people are putting up such a big fuss about illegal aliens crossing the border, but no one seems to care about all of the massive amounts of drugs coming over. I don't think opinions would change if they became legal residents they would just think of some other reason they shouldn't be here.
Posted by: hill at
January 12, 2007 05:45 PM
I am an intake counselor in the Human Services department for a large county in Nevada. In January, of the applicants I interviewed for receipt of social welfare benefits, 81% of them were undocumented aliens in this country seeking welfare benefits. Of that 81%, approximately 1/2 were trying to defraud the system by applying using their anchor children's social security number as their own.
SOMETHING needs to be done. We cannot afford this any longer!
Posted by: DHS Worker at
February 26, 2008 09:27 PM
It also turns out that California, Arizona and New Mexico are all in the top 10 for the highest ratio of students per teacher in K-12.
Mississippi, Arizona and Nevada are in the lowest 10 in terms of funding per student in K-12.
I've no idea what is going on in New Mexico.
Texas, which is in the middle of the pack, in terms of funding and student ratio is notoriously absent from the blogger's list, despite their high illegal immigrant rate.
Posted by: Joe Skeptical at
August 4, 2008 06:17 PM
Someone please send these statistics to Tom Horne of Arizona. He put out during a womans republican meeting that Arizona was in the top ten states for education this year. Maybe one school in the nation upset the statistical table but I am not even sure if if that was another misspeak or not.
Posted by: Brenda Conley at
August 15, 2008 11:31 AM
I love it when ignorant people speak. You honkies are amazing!!! I am a teacher in California and can testify that the students who most struggle are the AMERICAN born students. The immigrant students ALWAYS have stronger skills and are more critical thinkers. The ones who do badly are those who are exposed to our crappy education system all their lives. Check your stats and you will see almost every country does a better job at educating their youth--hence Venezuela being classified a completely literate nation along with Cuba and Boliva. Also the majority of students are BORN here, only 20 or 30 kids in a school of 2000 are illegal, and im no mathematician but 30 people can not have that great an impact on the numbers.
Posted by: Joan at
January 14, 2009 04:46 PM
Joan, get a clue. Maybe your California school only has 20-30 illegal students. My school (almost 3000 students) is 80 percent immigrant, I find it hard to believe that only 20-30 of those would be illegal. I find that those kids do struggle more than their "American born" counterparts. You seem to forget there is a huge language barrier for those students.
Posted by: dramateacherlady at
February 24, 2009 05:03 PM
dramateacherlady, you are making a huge mistake by thinking that most immigrant students are living in the U.S. illegally. This is totally FALSE. Just because someone comes to the U.S. from a different country does not mean they are doing it illegally. I must agree with Joan's statement. Most of the student I see struggling in my school (and neighboring schools) are American born children. Students who come from foreign countries generally receieve a much better education in their home country, but come to the U.S. because opportunities are more widely available. Check the statistics...and please re-think your position.
Posted by: MiamiTeacher at
April 1, 2009 07:23 PM
mybe joan teached physical education. in that case i would argue that immigrants are in much better shape than our kids.
Posted by: dallas at
April 3, 2009 08:01 PM
teached? mybe? huh? First off you should learn English. You also prove my point that natives are the ones who really struggle. Secondly I have a credential in English, History, Math and Special Education, thus I teach them all. But you are correct they are in better shape!
Posted by: Joan at
May 11, 2009 05:30 PM
This is what is meant by using ones common sense. The resourses of the tax paying public in America is not unlimited. We as Americans need to have politicians who live in the real world not some ivy tower where the real world is kept at arms length.
Whether it is education, health care, or welfare, we must for the sake of our survival become selfish, use our resourses for American citizens only.
What is this? Illeagal immegrants (mexican?)are causing the educational system to decline? really? The top graduates at my high school were all of Latin descent. And not until maybe 20 yrs ago it was predominantly white. the honor role...latino.Most peopple in sports...latino and our school was strict on keeping up your GPA to play. Immegrants arent the problem is the government they spend their money on stuff that isnt important and keep deducting the money givin to schools. that causes the educational system to go down because schools dont get provided with the amount of money to keep up to date. Thats fn stupid to say its illeagal immigrants. If it werent for immigrants non of us would be here. think about it if your so smart